Let’s Discuss: Reading Challenges – Pros vs Cons

Screen Shot 2015-06-08 at 12.33.05 PM

Considering how a lot of book bloggers (and even people in general) choose to participate in reading challenges, I thought it would be fun to discuss the pros and cons of doing so! (Disclaimer: I’m a mood reader so I don’t participate in reading challenges that often. Also, these are just my personal opinions so feel free to agree/disagree with me.)

The Pros

  1. I’m forced to take risks. In order to “win” a challenge like Bookish Bingo, I have to seek out books I might not usually read or expect to enjoy. I’ve actually had some success with this and discovered some 5-star reads. I even ended up reading some Historical Fiction – a genre I usually avoid because I find history boring for the most part. As a result of taking risks, I read a wider variety of books. This is different from taking risks because this means reading books that are already on my tbr but are yet unread because they were published a few years ago. These days I prioritize new releases and/r books that’ve been published up-to a year ago. This is because I want my reviews to be relevant, I get caught up in the book hype online and I want to be able to discuss these books with other bloggers (who have probably read them).
  2. Reading challenges (like the Banned Books Challenge) can help bring attention to under-appreciated books. Even though I haven’t tried the Banned Books Challenge yet, I know that reading banned books is probably fun because they’re interesting (and I mean the books were banned). 
  3. Some challenges help conquer the TBR pile. The TBR pile challenges encourages readers to read more books already on your tbr. I think this is great but I’m already chipping away at my TBR so I don’t really think I need a reading challenge to do that.
  4. Sometimes challenges help encourage you to read more diverse books. Diversity in literature is very important and as a POC myself, I’ve been pleased to see more books (2015 debuts included) by and featuring people of color.

The Cons

  1. Reading challenges can be harder for mood readers. In fact, I don’t like challenges that whittle down your options for what you can read because I don’t like being constrained. I want to have the power to pick and choose what I read – which is why I love the Goodreads Reading Challenge. My goal is to read 250 books this year but I’m actually trying not to take myself too seriously with this challenge and I’m just using it as a way to track how many books I read.
  2. Some challenges add more books to my TBR pile. Technically it’s a good thing when you discover more great books but when I’ve already got so many books on my tbr…well maybe I don’t need to join a challenge that means adding 20 more books that revolve around a particular theme!
  3. They can put you in a reading slump. In the past, my reading slumps have happened because I’ve been reading too much. Reading challenges can make me into an obsessive reader who only cares about the number of books I’ve read and not about the experience. And that means, reading isn’t fun anymore…it’s stressful! 

But in the end, reading, like all good things, should be done in moderation. So if you are going to participate in a reading challenge – make sure your #1 goal is to HAVE FUN and the rest will fall into place (…the stars will align and the book gods will… okay you get the idea!).

So what do you think? Do you agree with me? Disagree with me? Let me know in the comments!


18 thoughts on “Let’s Discuss: Reading Challenges – Pros vs Cons

  1. Its like you read my mind! You appear too know a lot about
    this, like you wrote the ook iin it or something. I think that
    you can do with some pics to drive the message home a little bit, but instead of that, this is fabtastic blog.
    A fantastic read. I will certainly be back.


  2. I started last year by joining some book challenges, and I promptly forgot about them after the first month. I just decided to ditch them all, except for the GR challenge, which I can thankfully change at the last minute to make myself look accomplished.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes I do love that about the GR challenge 😀 I might end up changing my goal actually if I get a lot busier at school next year. Who knows 😛


  3. The only reading challenge I do is the Good Reads one since it’s just a number. I see other various challenges that I think look ok, but it always seems like too much a hassle to sign up. And I’m a mood reader, too so having to read a specific kind of book wouldn’t really work for me.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Ah yes, me too! I signed up for one before but I only got through like half of it before ditching. I guess I just got tired pre-planning exactly what book I would have to read to win. Like you said, too much hassle!

      Liked by 1 person

    1. Yess I know what you mean! I’ve ditched a few in the past because eventually…idk I think I got tired of just reading books that fit the theme of that reading challenge so I just gave up and went back to reading whatever the hell I wanted 😛 I guess planning out *exactly* what I’m going to read for maybe the next 3-4 months just doesn’t work for me.


      1. lol I’ve done that on occasion 😀 Mostly I just go with stuff I got recently and what catches my fancy. If I’m hearing a ton about some book on twitter, then I know I’m gonna read it next or read it now.


      2. Well (thankfully) at the moment, I only have one or two ARCs being published each month for the next two months..so I can take my time reading them. 😛


  4. I’m a mood reader and I agree with everything above. I feel like reading challenges is the opposite of the actual purpose of reading, which is to have fun. I do participate this year since I love challenges. But I don’t stress about it too much. 😀

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Oh goodie! Another mood reader 😀 Well it’s good to hear your not stressing too much – hopefully you’re having fun too? 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Lol well that works too 😉 I guess in the end it doesn’t matter if you discover some good books in the process!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s